Draft Minutes of
AsCA Council Meeting:
Time: 11:40am 22 November 2006
Location: Room 304 Epochal Conference Center Tsukuba, Japan
In Attendance:
M. Vijayan (President) India mv@mbu.iisc.ernet.in
Mitchell Guss (Vice-President) Australia m.guss@mmb.usyd.edu.au
Ian D. Williams (Sec/Tres) Hong Kong chwill@ust.hk
Syd Hall (Trustee), Australia syd@crystal.uwa.edu.au
Y. Ohashi, (IUCr) Japan yohashi@spring8.or.jp
G. R. Desiraju, (IUCr) India gautam_desiraju@yahoo.com
Jenny Martin, Australia j.martin@imb.uq.edu.au
Chris Howard, Australia cjh@aristo.gov.au
Subrata Chandra Roy, Bangladesh scroy1979@yahoo.com
Zihe Rao, China raozh@nankai.edu.cn
J. K. Dattagupta, India jibank.dattagupta@saha.ac.in
K. Byrappa, India byrappak@yahoo.com
Kunio Miki, Japan miki@kuchem.kyoto-u.ac.jp
Masaki Takata, Japan takatama@spring8.or.jp
Young-Ja Park, Korea yjpark@sookmyung.ac.kr
Se Won Suh, Korea sewonsuh@snu.ac.kr
Ejaz Ahmed, Pakistan aejaz1@yahoo.com
Yu Wang, Taiwan wangyu@ntu.edu.tw
Shih Lin Chang, Taiwan slchang@phys.nthu.edu.tw
Chwan-Deng Hsiao, Taiwan hsiao@gate.sinica.eu.tw
Kenneth Haller, Thailand ken.haller@gmail.com
1.
President
Vijayan welcomed all council members to the meeting and especially IUCr
president Prof. Ohashi and IUCr representative Prof. Desiraju. He also
was pleased to announce that the organization now has a functioning web-site
thanks to the efforts of Dr. Sekar, and Profs. Guss
and Hall.
2.
Prof
Williams made a brief statement of the financial status of the society, based
on the accounts kindly provided by Prof. Hall the AsCA trustee. There had been
little financial activity since the past meeting. Some profits from AsCA04 Hong Kong had been
transferred to the AsCA account and member countries dues were almost
completely paid for 2005 and 2006. Outgoings were limited in the past two years, so that the total funds
had just exceeded A$100,000 for the first time. These were in a high interest bearing account
in Australia currently giving 6.33% effective yield. This was equivalent to an
accrual of a further A$500 per month in interest.
Whilst equities had been doing well it was the view that the funds should
remain in this short term deposit account for the foreseeable future, since in
addition to the high return the Australian dollar had appreciated about 34%
against many currencies over the past couple of years and this trend was likely
to remain intact. Discussion followed with general agreement that the society
was now in a strong enough fiscal position to provide some financial support to
young scientists for future AsCA conferences whilst maintaining the existing
capital of the account.
3.
The next
item was detailed power-point presentation of preparations for AsCA07
conference in Taipei. This was given by Prof S.L. Chang, Chairman of the Intl.
Organizing Committee. A number of changes had been made in light of comments
from the last council meeting held in Florence at IUCr2005. The venue had been moved to the Howard
International House in order to keep costs reasonable and for better logistics
for room size. The venue would have a
large convention hall capable of seating 733 and a second conference room for
220. A third room had capacity of 85, though
this could be increased to 100 if necessary through additional chairs. The exhibits and posters would be displayed
in corridors between these locations, with the plan being floors F1 and F2 for
exhibits and F3 and F4 for posters. Several comments were made that every
effort should be made to ensure that the exhibits from sponsor companies were
well integrated.
4.
The change
of location had necessitated a change of dates.
The new schedule was 4-7 November 2007. This had changed from November 10-13 as presented last year. The planned schedule follows recent model of
several AsCA events. 4 November 2007 will be Sunday and this will be for
registration and welcome reception/ opening ceremony. Mon-Wed would then have a full 3 day program
with 4 plenary sessions and six rounds (am and pm) of three parallel sessions,
fitting to 18 session topics planned by the program committee headed by Prof Suh.
5.
Prof Chang
next discussed details of accommodations and fees: 270 rooms had been reserved
for conference attendees in the Howard Intl House itself these were priced at US$60 for single
and US$110 for either double or twin rooms.
Further budget accommodation for students had been reserved in Youth
Activity Center 5km north of the venue these rooms
were US$50 for double or US$75 for room of four. Conference fees which include food, would be US$250 for full registrants, US$150 for
students. Cost of exhibitor booths would be set at US$1500. Discussion included the possibility of a
slightly modified scheme which had an early/late fee structure that could be
implemented by Prof Chang.
6.
Several
possibilities for important dates were then presented, with deadlines for
abstract submission and registration. After brief discussion deadlines of 30
June for abstract submission and 31 July for early registration were agreed
upon. Prof Vijayan stressed the need to compromise on dates and not set them
too early so that new science would be included. Prof Chang indicated that time for
publication of the abstract book would not be too lengthy. The abstract deadline could be extended if
deemed necessary.
7.
Prof Chang
indicated that a conference web-site had been constructed and that much
information would be now be included following the
finalization and agreement of details at AsCA06. Prof Guss requested a link to
the AsCA web-site and indicated he would reciprocate and set up a similar one
to the conference site.
8.
Next item
was a discussion of the plans for the academic program at AsCA07 led by Prof Se
Won Suh, Chairman of the Program Committee. He had prepared a final list of the program
committee members, which had been arrived at to provide breadth of expertise in
different disciplines and also have geographic balance. Some discussions
followed on the need to quickly identify plenary speakers. Prof Vijayan
mentioned that it would be 20th anniversary of AsCA in 2007 and
perhaps a special effort to obtain prominent speakers such as Nobel Laureates
Rod MacKinnon or Harmut Michel could be made. Prof Suh would work
closely with committee members to finalize the plenary lecturers in the near
future, so that Prof Chang could announce this on web-site as soon as possible.
9.
A list of
session topics for AsCA07 was also provided by Prof Suh. Some debate about the titles and content
followed. Prof Desiraju indicated that session 06.
‘Crystallography in Chemistry’ was too broad in scope whilst Prof Hall
commented that session 17. ‘Computational crystallography of proteins’ did not
need to be limited to proteins. One difficulty was that the topics might lead
to exclusion of other work. Thus
‘requests for abstracts’ should make clear that any work in structural biology,
materials science and chemistry could also be submitted and was not limited to
the advertised session topics. Some
modifications/ rearrangement of final program could be made by the program
committee after all abstracts had been received and the popularity of topics
assessed.
10.
At this
point Prof Ohashi discussed some of the IUCr policies
as affecting AsCA and the region. One
goal was to increase the number of adhering countries. In AsCA only seven countries were affiliated
with IUCr as Category I and paid membership fees. Since the current fee of
US$800 per year might be too high for small developing nations it was decided
that several such countires could apply jointly and
pay a single shared fee. This might be
done through AsCA and decision was made that this be formalized at the next
council meeting in AsCA07. The smaller nations would pay subscriptions to AsCA
and then AsCA would pay one fee to IUCr on behalf of the group of nations. In return the block of countries would be
allowed to have one representative with voting rights at the IUCr general
assembly meeting.
11.
Prof Desiraju mentioned that as part of his role on IUCr council
he needed to report briefly on the activities in the region. Prof Williams
agreed to prepare a few paragraphs covering the period to end 2006 for
inclusion in next Summer’s report at ECM.
12.
Next
agenda items were the discussion of possible venues for AsCA09 and AsCA10.The AsCA09 was intended to be a joint meeting
of AsCA with a national society, as held in Broome in 2003 and Japan in 2006.
In principle this could only be held in a country with an existing active
national society. Both China and Korea
were considered. Prof Suh and Park indicated that Korea held national meeting
with about 100 crystallographers. It was
the consensus that China be allowed to prepare plans for the AsCA09 conference.
Prof Rao indicated that he would be willing to assist in preparation of a bid
from China which would be presented next year in Taipei. He praised the
organizational plans for next year’s meeting there, but commented that there
were still sensitivities about nomenclature for Taiwan and that AsCA should be
mindful of this. He was assured that
AsCA is non-political as required by IUCr policy.
13.
Prof
Haller then briefly presented a bid for AsCA10 on behalf of Suranaree
University of Technology in Nakhon Ratchasima, Thailand. The intention would be to hold the event on the university campus. Three large conference rooms would be available. There was also sufficient local hotel
capacity to provide accommodation. Costs
were relatively low. The weather in November would be quite comfortable ca 25oC.
One noteworthy point was that the university was the site of Thailand
synchrotron. Prof Guss noted that Thailand had infact
hosted AsCA in 1995 at Chulalongkorn University,
Bangkok and that perhaps other nations should be given a chance to host the
meeting first. Profs Suh
and Park were encouraged to promote a bid from Korea to host AsCA10.
14.
Prof. Guss
raised the issues about revision of country fee structures which should
probably be formally reviewed and updated at AsCA07 and also support for young
scientists to attend AsCA meetings. Prof Hall intimated that some support
(several thousand A$) for this could be supplied from the AsCA financial
account as long as the principal remained intact. Prof. S.L. Chang requested information on the
appropriate amount to request from IUCr for young scientist support for
AsCA07. It was stated that recent
meetings that US$12,000 had been awarded and that this was the appropriate
amount.
15. Meeting was adjourned with thanks from Prof Vijayan for the attendance and contribution of those present at 1.15pm.